Keywords
Ethics, scientific publication, instructions to authors, editorial policy, scientific fraud, Social Sciences, Spain, Latin America
Abstract
The process of publishing scientific papers should be based on universal principles of professional conduct: credibility, truth and authenticity. In academia, the inclusion of policies on ethical standards in journal instructions to authors could prevent misconduct and fraud in scientific publication. Due to the lack of attention to research ethics in the Social Sciences, in particular in Spain and Latin America, this research aims to analyze the scientific misconduct policy of the Spanish and Latin American journals in the JCR-Social Sciences Edition (2014). To achieve our goal, 104 selected journal instructions to authors were examined in relation to the following ethical principles: (1) the rights of people involved in the research; (2) the welfare of animals used in research; (3) conflicts of interest; and (4) publication issues. Our results suggest that publication issues such as unpublished research and the ban on simultaneous submission are the most frequently cited ethical issues. In spite of the efforts made by policy-making bodies to establish misconduct guidelines, very few journals adhere to ICMJE and COPE recommendations. Given the ethical heterogeneity evinced by our study, and by previous studies, it seems that the development of a uniform code of ethics in the field of Social Sciences may be required.
References
Link DOI | Link Google Scholar
Atlas, M.C. (2003). Emerging Ethical Issues in Instructions to Authors of High-impact Biomedical Journals. Journal of the Medical Library Association, 91(4), 442-449 (http://goo.gl/A7mPQY) (14/10/2015).
Link DOI | Link Google Scholar
Baiget, T. (2010). Ética en revistas científicas. Ibersid, 4, 59-65 (http://goo.gl/3pRk1x) (2016-03-07).
Baiget, T., & Torres-Salinas, D. (2013). Informe APEI sobre publicación en revistas científicas. Gijón: Asociación Profesional de Especialistas en Información (http://goo.gl/ZjjwOV) (2015-10-14).
Link DOI | Link Google Scholar
Link DOI | Link Google Scholar
Link DOI | Link Google Scholar
Brackbill, Y., & Hellegers, A.E. (1980). Ethics and Editors. Hastings Center Report, 10(2), 20-24.
Link DOI | Link Google Scholar
Camargo, O. (2012). La autoría inmerecida en las publicaciones. Revista Redbioética/UNESCO, 1(5), 19-31 (http://goo.gl/OB6mRL) (2015-10-14).
Campanario, J.M. (2003). Cómo escribir y publicar un artículo científico: cómo estudiar y aumentar su impacto. Revista española de documentación científica, 26(4), 461-463 (http://goo.gl/76bV9U) (2015-10-14).
Committee on Publication Ethics (COPE) (2011). Responsible Research Publication: International Standards for Authors (http://goo.gl/dbru5Y) (2015-10-14).
Delgado, E., & Ruiz, R. (2009). La comunicación y edición científica: fundamentos conceptuales. In C. García, & J. Vílchez (Coords.), Homenaje a Isabel de Torres Ramírez: estudios de documentación dedicados a su memoria (pp. 131-150). Granada: Universidad de Granada (http://goo.gl/l0Brd9) (2015-10-14).
Delgado, E., Ruiz-Pérez, R., & Jiménez-Contreras, E. (2006). La edición de revistas científicas: directrices, criterios y modelos de evaluación. Madrid: Fundación Española para la Ciencia y la Tecnología (http://goo.gl/swj8fe) (2015-10-14).
Delgado, E., Torres-Salinas, D., & Roldán, A. (2007). El fraude en la ciencia: reflexiones a partir del caso Hwang. El Profesional de la Información, 16(2), 143-150 (http://goo.gl/Cr6L4L) (2015-10-14).
Link DOI | Link Google Scholar
Link DOI | Link Google Scholar
Link DOI | Link Google Scholar
International Committee of Medical Journal Editors (ICMJE) (2014). Recommendations for the Conduct, Reporting, Editing and Publication of Scholarly Work in Medical Journals (http://goo.gl/HQEfH5) (2015-10-14).
Link DOI | Link Google Scholar
Link DOI | Link Google Scholar
Link DOI | Link Google Scholar
Link DOI | Link Google Scholar
Tur-Viñes, V., Fonseca-Mora, M.C., & San-Miguel-Gutiérrez, B. (2013). Ética y conflictos de autoría en la publicación científica. La opinión del editor. In G. González, J. Gómez, & V. Agulló (Coords.), La colaboración científica: una aproximación multidisciplinar (pp.153-165). Valencia: Nau Llibres.
Fundref
This work has no financial support
Technical information
Received: 03-11-2015
Revised: 15-12-2015
Accepted: 22-02-2016
OnlineFirst: 15-05-2016
Publication date: 01-07-2016
Article revision time: 42 days | Average time revision issue 48: 29 days
Article acceptance time: 111 days | Average time of acceptance issue 48: 73 days
Preprint editing time: 195 days | Average editing time preprint issue 48: 157 days
Article editing time: 240 days | Average editing time issue 48: 202 days
Metrics
Metrics of this article
Views: 27453
Abstract readings: 22264
PDF downloads: 5189
Full metrics of Comunicar 48
Views: 434031
Abstract readings: 310911
PDF downloads: 123120
Cited by
Cites in Web of Science
Izarra Vielma, Douglas A.; Valentina Romero, Paola; . Ethics in the scientific communication: an overview through education journals PRAXIS SOCIOLOGICA, 2017.
Diaz-Campo, Jesus; Segado-Boj, Francisco; . The authorship conflicts in journals of the Journal Citation Reports (JCR). Ethical criteria in the education journals BID-TEXTOS UNIVERSITARIS DE BIBLIOTECONOMIA I DOCUMENTACIO, 2017.
Arias-Flores, Hugo; Maldonado, Cesar Guevara; Jadan-Guerrero, Janio; Bonilla-Jurado, Diego; . A look at investigation through open journal system and screen reading systems REVISTA PENSAMIENTO AMERICANO, 2018.
https://doi.org/10.21803/pensam.v11i21.148
Hosseini, Mohammad; Gordijn, Bert; . A review of the literature on ethical issues related to scientific authorship SCIENCE COMMUNICATION, 2020.
https://doi.org/10.1080/08989621.2020.1750957
Dolores Meneses-Fernandez, Maria; Dolores Santana-Hernandez, Juana; . JOURNALISTIC CONSTRUCTION OF SCIENTIFIC MALPRACTICE: ANALYSIS IN DIGITAL NEWS MEDIA PRISMA SOCIAL, 2020.
#EANF#; . Editorial transparency in Mexican scientific journals on Education: Towards a comprehensive management of editorial policies in scientific periodicals Investigación bibliotecológica, 2021.
https://doi.org/10.22201/iibi.24488321xe.2021.87.58340
Fernandez Bajon, Maria Teresa; Guerra Gonzalez, Jenny Teresita; . Editorial transparency in Mexican scientific journals on Education: Towards a comprehensive management of editorial policies in scientific periodicals REVISTA ESPANOLA DE DOCUMENTACION CIENTIFICA, 0.
#EANF#; . Further reflections on the editorial policy of Medicentro Electronic Journal Medicentro Electrónica, 2018.
Cites in Scopus
Hosseini, M., Gordijn, B. . A review of the literature on ethical issues related to scientific authorship), Accountability in Research, .
https://doi.org/10.1080/08989621.2020.1750957
Díaz-Campo, J., Segado-Boj, F.. Els conflictes d'autoria en les revistes del Journal Citation Reports (JCR). Criteris ètics en les revistes d'educació), BiD, .
Meneses-Fernández, M.D., Santana-Hernández, J.D. . Journalistic construction of scientific malpractice: Analysis in digital news media | [Construcción periodística de la mala praxis científica: Análisis en diarios digitales]), Prisma Social, .
Bajón, M.T.F., González, J.T.G. . Editorial transparency in Mexican scientific journals on education: Towards a comprehensive management of editorial policies in scientific periodicals | [Transparencia editorial en revistas científicas Mexicanas de educación: Hacia una gestión integral de las políticas editoriales en las publicaciones periódicas científicas]), Investigacion Bibliotecologica, .
https://doi.org/10.22201/iibi.24488321xe.2021.87.58340
Malički, M., Jerončić, A., Aalbersberg, I.J.J., Bouter, L., ter Riet, G.. Systematic review and meta-analyses of studies analysing instructions to authors from 1987 to 2017), Nature Communications, .
Cites in Google Scholar
Damasio, E. (2017). Práticas de má conduta na comunicação científica e o fluxo editorial: um estudo com editores de revistas científicas SciELO.
http://repositorio.ibict.br/handle/123456789/946
Fernández-Ramos, A. (2017). Estrategias y herramientas tecnológicas para evitar el plagio académico. In La infodiversidad y el uso ético del conocimiento individual y colectivo (pp. 253-275). IIBI, UNAM.
http://eprints.rclis.org/31326/
Díaz-Campo, J., & Segado-Boj, F. (2017). Los conflictos de autoría en las revistas del Journal Citation Reports (JCR). Criterios éticos en las revistas de educación. BiD, (39).
López de la Cruz, Y. (2018). Further reflections on the editorial policy of Medicentro Electronic Journal. Medicentro, 22(1), 102-105.
https://www.medigraphic.com/pdfs/medicentro/cmc-2018/cmc181r.pdf
Rojas, S. J. O., & Urizar, C. A. (2018). Desconocimiento sobre plagio en estudiantes de ciencias de la salud. Discover Medicine, 2(1), 9-10.
https://www.revdiscovermedicine.com/index.php/inicio/article/view/121
DÍAZ-CAMPO, J. E. S. Ú. S., & SEGADO-BOJ, F. R. A. N. C. I. S. C. O. (2017). Els conflictes d'autoria en les revistes del Journal Citation Reports (JCR). Criteris ètics en les revistes d'educació.
López de la Cruz, Y. (2018). Otra reflexión sobre política editorial de la revista Medicentro Electrónica. Medicentro Electrónica, 22(1), 102-105.
http://scielo.sld.cu/scielo.php?script=sci_arttext&pid=S1029-30432018000100018
Vielma, D. A. I., & Romero, P. V. (2017). Ética en la comunicación científica: una visión en revistas del área de la educación. Praxis sociológica, (22), 65-80.
https://dialnet.unirioja.es/servlet/articulo?codigo=6313644
Lorenzo, S. (2018). Presencia de la comunidad científica de investigadores de la Universidad Central “Marta Abreu” de Las Villas en la Web (Doctoral dissertation, Universidad Central “Marta Abreu” de Las Villas).
http://dspace.uclv.edu.cu/handle/123456789/10187
Hosseini, M., & Gordijn, B. (2020). A review of the literature on ethical issues related to scientific authorship. Accountability in Research, (just-accepted).
https://www.tandfonline.com/doi/abs/10.1080/08989621.2020.1750957
Alternative metrics
How to cite
Hernández-Ruiz, A. (2016). Antifraud editorial policy in Spanish and Latin American scientific publication: JCR social sciences edition. [La política editorial antifraude de las revistas científicas españolas e iberoamericanas del JCR en ciencias sociales]. Comunicar, 48, 19-27. https://doi.org/10.3916/C48-2016-02